Supreme draft is an odd format where players only draft first picks. It takes a ton of cards and is a bit unwieldy, but facilitates some truly outlandish gameplay moments.

How to Play

Each player opens a pack, picks two cards into their draft pool, and then discard the rest of the pack. Repeat this process 18 times.

Since this format requires a number of cards equal to 18×(number of players)×(pack size), it can be difficult to support large numbers of players. Tweak the pack size down to 10 or 8 if necessary, or pause halfway through to shuffle all the discarded cards into fresh packs.


Supreme draft can lead to completely bonkers draft pools, with sky-high card quality compared to a regular draft. It’s also easy to draft exactly what a deck needs in order to support any synergies or off-the-wall strategies, creating Rotisserie-like decks.

That said, it is also possible that the ease of constructing a manabase and collecting power outliers can lead to bomb-heavy gameplay patterns that might not suit all player preferences. The logistics can also be a challenge compared to other two-player draft formats.


Supreme draft was designed for Magic Online and first introduced by Ali Steele.

Draft Formats

Lucky Paper is a group of friends spending their free time creating resources, articles, and podcasts to support sandbox Magic formats. Have questions, comments, or corrections? Get in touch!

Lucky Paper Newsletter

Our infrequent, text-only newsletter is a friendly way to stay up-to-date with what we’re doing at Lucky Paper. See past newsletters

Supreme VerdictSam Burley